feature | daily | high gear | we::blog | contact      
 
Search
Daily News
Web Search
Anyone can submit a news item, but only members can comment on them! New users, sign up here.
 
  danchan Login  
  Nickname  
   
  Password  
   
  Remember  
   

New openlog - the unbearable lightness of blog - plus free weblogging with comments, easy syndication and no ads!

Get [danchan] for your PDA!

Every daily news item!

10 latest comments

  Archive  
  2001 December
2001 November
2001 October
2001 September
2001 August
2001 July
2001 June
2001 May
2001 April
2001 March
2001 February
2001 January
2000 December
2000 November
2000 October
2000 September
2000 August
2000 July
2000 June
 
 
14 Jun 2001  


Kuro5hin and the "Social Text Affair"

I learned of another Slashdot-like site called Kuro5hin.org and I found a story there that revealed a hoax in a previously submitted story about Rasterisation as Art. The author of the Rasterisation hoax cited Alan Sokal's experiment on the editors of "Social Text" as inspiration. The experiment involved Sokal writing a Physics is Mystic parody piece, peppering it with big name quotes, and ideas that were fashionable at the time. When the article, titled "Transgressing the Boundaries: Toward a Transformative Hermeneutics of Quantum Gravity", was published in "Social Text", Sokal exposed his experiment in "Lingua Franca", where he clarifies his intentions in the writing of the original article:

I decided to try a modest (though admittedly uncontrolled) experiment: Would a leading North American journal of cultural studies -- whose editorial collective includes such luminaries as Fredric Jameson and Andrew Ross -- publish an article liberally salted with nonsense if (a) it sounded good and (b) it flattered the editors' ideological preconceptions?

It all sounds kind of fun, like a big fat pie in the face of the all the pedantic mumbo-jumbo out there. Sokal wants to point out that much of subjectivist thinking is mired in "obscure and pretentious language." But it also sounds a bit like gloating. HAHA! Suckers! Then before I can really think things through (my head still reeling from the dense, incomprehensible writing of "Transgressing...") and judge Sokal -- is he right or is he an ass? -- I realize that this is Sokal's university home page, the place where most scholars would collect their academic work. And every link on the page of this Professor of Physics concerns the hoax, called the "Social Text Affair". Will this be his claim to fame?

Publish or perish, I suppose.

0 comments
 
  DAYPOP  
Searching the Living Web
Daypop indexes news sites and weblogs every day to give you the latest relevant information.

Weblogging

Super-customizable weblogging with comments
Add comments to your web site or create a weblog of your own!

Web Caching
Accelerate your website!
Improve your website's responsiveness by preloading your site content into a user's browser cache.

Recent Features

Dell Inspiron 4000 Review
theVooner reviews the Dell Inspiron 4000

Sony CLIE 760C Review
theVooner reviews Sony's color Palm
theVooner's Christmas 2001 Wishlist
Cool gadgets for Christmas 2001

Ericsson T68 Mobile Phone Review
theVooner reviews Ericsson's color screen T68

Toshiba Libretto L2 Review
theVooner's newest sub-notebook

Alfred Dunhill Carbon Fibre
Space-age materials in theVooner's newest pen

Ericsson T39 Mobile Phone and Bluetooth Headset Review
The Bluetooth Headset is a winner in theVooner's book

Sony MZ5 Cellular Phone Review
theVooner's take on convergent technology in the Sony MZ5 Cellular Phone/ATRAC player

Sony DSC-S85 4.1 Megapixel Digital Camera Review
theVooner reviews the newest Sony 4.1 Megapixel Digital Camera

Fujitsu PDS4221 - 42" Plasma Display Review
theVooner reviews his new Fujitsu Plasma TV

Bald Cap
danchan tries out a new look for an afternoon

Sony RM-VZ950T Universal Remote Commander Review
theVooner reviews Sony's Universal Remote Commander

New Yorkers visit Los Angeles
Memorial Day Weekend Reunion in L.A.

NYC and Yale Graduation Trip
My sister graduates from Yale

Sharp LC-15A2 15" LCD TV Review
theVooner reviews Sharp's 15" LCD TV

Casio Wrist Camera Review
danchan reviews the Casio Wrist Camera

Gameboy Advance Review
theVooner reviews the next generation Gameboy

Nokia 8890 Review
theVooner reviews the Nokia 8890

Bang & Olufsen Beocom 6000 Cordless Phone Review
theVooner reviews Bang & Olufsen's stylish cordless phone

Fuji Instax Mini 10 & Polaroid iZone Instant Camera Reviews
theVooner reviews two instant cameras that are all the rage in Japan
Questions? Comments? Send all mail to: dc@danchan.com