|
Kuro5hin and the "Social Text Affair"
I learned of another Slashdot-like site called Kuro5hin.org
and I found a story
there that revealed a hoax in a previously submitted story about Rasterisation
as Art. The author of the Rasterisation hoax cited Alan
Sokal's experiment on the editors of "Social
Text" as inspiration. The experiment involved Sokal writing a Physics
is Mystic parody piece, peppering it with big name quotes, and ideas that
were fashionable at the time. When the article, titled "Transgressing
the Boundaries: Toward a Transformative Hermeneutics of Quantum Gravity",
was published in "Social Text", Sokal exposed his experiment in "Lingua
Franca", where he clarifies his intentions in the writing of the original
article:
I decided to try a modest (though admittedly uncontrolled) experiment: Would
a leading North American journal of cultural studies -- whose editorial collective
includes such luminaries as Fredric Jameson and Andrew Ross -- publish an
article liberally salted with nonsense if (a) it sounded good and (b) it flattered
the editors' ideological preconceptions?
It all sounds kind of fun, like a big fat pie in the face of the all the pedantic
mumbo-jumbo out there. Sokal wants to point out that much of subjectivist thinking
is mired in "obscure and pretentious language." But it also sounds
a bit like gloating. HAHA! Suckers! Then before I can really think
things through (my head still reeling from the dense, incomprehensible writing
of "Transgressing...") and judge Sokal -- is he right or is
he an ass? -- I realize that this
is Sokal's university home page, the place where most scholars would collect
their academic work. And every link on the page of this Professor of Physics
concerns the hoax, called the "Social Text Affair". Will this be his
claim to fame?
Publish or perish, I suppose.
|